European. Polite contrarian. Linux enthusiast. History graduate. I never downvote reasoned opinions and I do not engage with people who downvote mine (which may be why you got no reply). Low-effort comments with vulgarity or snark will also be ignored.

  • 4 Posts
  • 110 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 16th, 2023

help-circle





  • Interesting take, and maybe you are a kind of pioneer.

    Actually, I’ve done something a bit similar in that I use my mobile device (“smartphone”) a lot less than a decade ago. It had got to point where I was doing everything on Android (i.e. like most people today). I said STOP to that and moved gradually back to the laptop. Now I have a tiny smartphone (4-in Cubot) which I use for the same things as 15 years ago: mapping, photos, podcasts and that’s about it, certainly nothing social (nothing at all, including messaging, if you can believe it). Pretty radical but it’s been a liberation, similar to your experience.



  • Obviously you’re right about the economics of it. The problem is the arbitrariness factor. I personally don’t much like that. In 25 years I only ever bought a secondhand computer once (a Compaq laptop!) and… it ended up failing on me (HDD). Then there’s the battery issue. I am very careful with my hardware (including keeping the battery within its range) and I know that I will get X years out of it if nobody else has touched it. I agree that secondhand is cheaper overall and certainly greener.

    PS: I like that Yoga a lot!



  • Not because of the price of the hardware (see my previous remark) but because I see little reasons to be optimistic about the future of the “general purpose” computers in general. And even less reason to be optimistic about the respect of our freedom and privacy on that computer. It almost already is a lost fight on our mobile devices. And it’s a fight we are losing on the political/societal level. At the same speed we’re being un-learned, so to speak, of the core values of what being a citizen in a democracy is supposed to mean.

    But that is a whole different story.

    It’s the subtext to my whole post. I completely share your take.




  • OK points taken, but I’ll push back a bit about these definitions of “normal”.

    What I aspire to is a tablet with a keyboard. I would argue that this makes me very normal indeed. This is not “abnormal hardware” any more, it’s basically the step up from smartphones, which is what ordinary people do their computing on these days.

    These days desktop computers are bought by corporations and gamers only, and laptops are bought by students and rich people. Ordinary people use Android. Hence my whole issue.



  • Fair points. I actually earned more 20 years ago than I do today, but that’s on me. In retrospect the real golden age IMO was the netbook era. Those things were Linux-compatible and there was tons of competition so they were cheap as dirt. I had an Asus that cost next to nothing and ended up taking 6 years of constant abuse (in a backpack).

    Yes, I’ve heard about Lenovo T line and I don’t doubt they’re great. A bit too heavy and frankly high performance for me. And it still feels like a temporary solution, like driving a 1980s car because they don’t make them like they did.

    If the Pinebook Pro was in stock I probably would have bought that.



  • Yep, good summary. And correct, the keyboard bit was ambiguous - I would totally buy a “big tablet with a keyboard” if I could easily put Linux on it. But they’re more or less all Android now, and even Chromebook laptops are dying out.

    The Framework is just too expensive to justify but otherwise it would be an okay compromise. I just paid literally half that price for the same specs and weight (less modular, sure). A decade ago I paid even less (230€!) for an Intel netbook. Non-existent today.



  • The teardown video is available. It’s a 100-stage process involving specialized tools. I know my limits.

    But even if you do, it’s just “buy laptop, install Linux”.

    Not for less than a grand it isn’t. Not today. For reasons outlined. Go and check. The situation has changed.

    buy a Mac

    So you don’t think it’s a big deal if non-techie users without 1000 bucks to spare cannot use a computer with an OS under their control? I do.

    Disappointed with the flippancy (not to mention predictable bitterness and mockery) of the comments here. I want FOSS to succeed. I thought people here too did.