Give me the Death Note, I can be trusted to act rationally. The only “undeserving” to end up on it would be people who step through Metro doors and immediately stop, even though there’s people behind them.
More seriously I know the author has said it’s about power corrupting, but if that’s the story he wanted to tell then he should’ve chosen a different protagonist. Its also a silly mantra, we do not live in a Tolkien novel, power isn’t some supernatural force.


That book belongs in the hands of a thoughtful, strategic mind. Carefully select a target, watch what happens, then follow up similarly.
“The biggest problem with Kira is that he didn’t kill the people I would have killed”
I mean, yes. That is one of the big pieces of criteria against the text, that it took someone who was already a demented power hungry individual, instead of someone with any kind of solid ideological backbone.
Give the Death Note to a zapatista or the lawyer imprisoned by Exxon.
edit: Are we going to pretend the world would not be a better place if people like Epstein gave up all their money, shared all their documents and then jumped off a cliff as soon as they were known publically?
The amount of claims approved by United healthcare skyrocketed as soon as one CEO got shot. The ‘moonies’ cults political influence was dismantled following the murder of Shinzo Abe.
The idea that the violent supernatural death + sharing of all incriminating evidence by people like Hillary Clinton, Bill Clinton, Donald Trump, George Bush, Netanyahu, Jeb Bush, Rumsfeld, Putin, Newland, Gingrich, Maxwell, Diddy, Gates, Bezos, Musk, Weinstein, Dutreaux, all fortune 500 executives, almost all employees at Pentagon, all US generals, most major news editors, and son on; wouldnt make the world a better place, seems childish.
This is predicated on a Great Man of History understanding of the world. As much as we would like to believe Doohickeying Shinzo Abe will change the world, he is but a cog in a much larger machine as evidenced by his protege taking control of the county so quickly after his death.
You simply cannot kill your way to a better world. The Death Note is a fascist fantasy. All it can do it polarizer people against you.
Killing Abe did have plenty of good knock-on effects. Great Man Theory isn’t just “acknowledging that there are influential people in the world”.
By your criteria, Marx is doing great man theory when he writes
You can kill your way to a better world, but it’s chip damage - the improvements are a rounding error.
Only because you dont have a magical book that lets you force the victim to do pretty much whatever you want before they die AND you choose their method of death AND there’s no way of tracing it (unless you’re an idiot like L) nor of stopping it.